Comparison of Dylan Thomas Fern Hill and Robert Frosts Birches Essay

Comparison of Dylan Thomas Fern Hill and Robert icings Birches Poets often use nature vision to comment on the affinity between humans and the natural environment surrounding them. Traditionally, this relationship is portrayed in a positive manner as it places emphasis on the concept that nature is representative of beauty consequently, embracing this representation will enlighten the human experience. The facets of that relationship are represented inside Dylan Thomas Fern Hill and Robert Frosts Birches. Both poets invoke an image of nature that is picturesque, serene and innocent in order to convey a message that one can hold in a fulfilling life if they focus on the beauty that exists within the primary world. Conversely, Coleridges Dejection An Ode contains a different interpretation of what ones relationship with nature should involve. The speaker feels that a simple ap preciation of beauty is insufficient one must identify with that beauty through the soul in order to be enlightened. Despite the point that Fern Hill and Birches initially appear to express satisfaction about the value of superficial human experiences, when analyzed in conjunction with Dejection An Ode, the meanings of these two poems are altered. Frosts Birches, Thomas Fern Hill and Coleridges Dejection An Ode all convey different levels of dejection upon initial examination however, when contrasting the expressions of the speaker and the imagery patterns of the poem, these levels of dejection become increasingly ambiguous. The relationship between the... ...rly, all three poems contain elements of dejection at one point however, the presence of that dejection is tested in Coleridges case, and increased within the Frost and Thomas poems. It is incredibly ironic that the one poem that was an ode to dejection turned out to be the most positive of the t hree. WORKS CITED Coleridge, Samuel Taylor. Dejection An Ode. The Broadview Anthology of Poetry. Eds. Herbert Rosengarten and Amanda Goldrick-Jones. Peterborough Broadview P, 1993. 183. Frost, Robert. Birches. The Broadview Anthology of Poetry. Eds. Herbert Rosengarten and Amanda Goldrick-Jones. Peterborough Broadview P, 1993. 410. Thomas, Dylan. Fern Hill. The Broadview Anthology of Poetry. Eds. Herbert Rosengarten and Amanda Goldrick-Jones. Peterborough Broadview P, 1993. 632.